Sternglas Berlin AutomatikvsMagrette Tourer

Owners widely praise the Sternglas Berlin Automatik for its handsome, clean dial and a 38mm size that fits smaller wrists well, making it a comfortable daily wearer. The case is described as solid and well-finished. However, the Miyota 8205 movement is noted as reliable but noticeably loud, and the exhibition caseback is unadorned. Some owners find the watch too simple and question the value, citing basic movement and strap choices for the price, with a few feeling the proportions and day/date complication are off. Overall, owners appreciate the Sternglas Berlin Automatik for its classic design and wearability, though some debate its value proposition.

The Magrette Tourer is praised for its vintage race car aesthetic, solid build, and quality materials at a good value. Reviewers note its perfect legibility with a restrained, gentlemanly yet masculine presence. However, the yellow-tinted display caseback and raw rotor detract from its refined feel, and aligning the inner bezel can be frustratingly difficult due to crown movement when screwed down. The Magrette Tourer uses a Miyota 9015 movement with a 42-hour power reserve and accuracy rated at -10/+30 seconds per day. Overall, reviewers find the Magrette Tourer to be a good value with a vintage charm, despite minor frustrations with the inner bezel alignment.