Fears Sherbert Yellow
Finding alternatives to

Fears Sherbert Yellow

Ref. redcliff-39-5-sherbert-yellow

53 watches that match on case size, movement family, and price band. Sorted by how close the match is.

Case
39.5mm
Movement
Automatic
Category
Sport
MSRP
$2,292
The short answer

The closest alternative to the Fears Sherbert Yellow is the Yema Wristmaster Slim CMM.20 ($2,117) — common cross-shop and Looks nearly identical. If price is the constraint, the Hamilton Jazzmaster Thinline Auto at $1,145 (vs $2,292 for the Sherbert Yellow) covers most of the same brief. From the independents, the Fears Redcliff 39.5 is the standout microbrand take — shared caliber (La Joux-Perret G101) and Same family (Redcliff 39.5). Stepping up, the Grand Seiko SBGM221 ($5,400) is where the same idea goes with a bigger budget.

53 matches
Microbrand picks· 12

Independent makers covering the same brief — usually with something the mainstream brands don't.

Fears
Redcliff 39.5
39.5mm · Automatic$2,458
Shared caliber (La Joux-Perret G101) · Same family (Redcliff 39.5)
Astor + Banks
Fortitude Lite
38.5mm · Automatic$650
Common cross-shop · Looks nearly identical
anOrdain
Model 2
41mm · Manual$2,673
Common cross-shop · Looks nearly identical
Studio Underd0g
Classic Cheese (Gen3)
38.5mm · Automatic$625
Common cross-shop · Visually similar
anOrdain
Model 2 Porcelain
39.5mm · Automatic$2,356
Common cross-shop · Shared caliber (La Joux-Perret G101)
anOrdain
Fabrik
38mm · Automatic$1,810
Common cross-shop · Shared caliber (La Joux-Perret G101)
Praesidus
Pathfinder 44
38mm · Automatic$550
Visually similar · Automatic
Studio Underd0g
The Gimlet
39.5mm · Manual$1,000
Common cross-shop · Visually similar
Studio Underd0g
The Mimosa
39.5mm · Manual$1,000
Common cross-shop · Visually similar
Vario
1918 Medic Brass
40mm · Automatic$388
Common cross-shop · Automatic
Galo
Enamel
38.5mm · Automatic$282
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Cincinnati Watch Company
P-40 A-11 Pilot
38mm · Automatic$695
Common cross-shop · Visually similar
Mainstream picks· 12

Established brands covering the same brief at a comparable price — same case size, similar movement family. Often the deciding click for a new buyer.

Yema
Wristmaster Slim CMM.20
39mm · Automatic$2,117
Common cross-shop · Looks nearly identical
Yema
Flygraf CPA10
40mm · Automatic$1,614
Common cross-shop · Automatic
Hamilton
American Classic Intra-Matic Auto
40mm · Automatic$1,275
Common cross-shop · Visually similar
Yema
Navygraf Phantom CMM.10 Limited Edition
38.5mm · Automatic$2,090
Common cross-shop · Automatic
NOMOS Glashütte
Orion 38 silver
38mm · Manual$3,060
Looks nearly identical · Similar size
Chrobry
40.3mm · Automatic$2,433
Visually similar · Automatic
Oris
ORIS SOCIAL CLUB Barcelona
40mm · Automatic$2,600
Automatic · Same size
Seiko
Presage Classic Series “Craftsmanship” Urushi Lacquer Dial
40.2mm · Automatic$1,650
Common cross-shop · Automatic
Seiko
Presage Classic Series “Craftsmanship” Unglazed Arita Porcelain Dial Limited Edition
40.6mm · Automatic$1,850
Common cross-shop · Automatic
Seiko
King Seiko KS1969
39.4mm · Automatic$3,100
Common cross-shop · Automatic
Oris
Wings of Hope Limited Edition
40mm · Automatic$4,300
Automatic · Same size
Hamilton
American Classic Intra-Matic Chronograph H
40mm · Manual$2,495
Common cross-shop · Same size
Cheaper alternatives· 12

If the price is the only thing keeping you off this watch, these get you most of the way there for less.

Hamilton
Jazzmaster Thinline Auto
40mm · Automatic$1,145
Common cross-shop · Visually similar
Seiko
Presage Classic Series Upcycled Leather Strap Limited Edition
40.2mm · Automatic$1,050
Common cross-shop · Visually similar
Alkin Watches
Model Three Dual Time
40.5mm · Automatic$582
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Tissot
Classic Dream
40mm · Automatic$550
Common cross-shop · Visually similar
Seiko
Presage Classic Series
40.2mm · Automatic$950
Common cross-shop · Visually similar
Orient
Stretto Date
38.5mm · Automatic$360
Common cross-shop · Visually similar
Seiko
Presage Classic Series
40.2mm · Automatic$1,125
Common cross-shop · Automatic
Citizen
Zenshin 60 Mechanical
40.5mm · Automatic$581
Common cross-shop · Visually similar
Tissot
Le Locle Open Heart
39.3mm · Automatic$995
Common cross-shop · Automatic
Orient
Bambino Version 4
42mm · Automatic$275
Common cross-shop · Looks nearly identical
Citizen
Series 8 831
40mm · Automatic$1,095
Common cross-shop · Automatic
Tissot
Heritage 1938
39mm · Automatic$925
Common cross-shop · Automatic
Pricier alternatives· 12

Where the same idea goes when budget isn't the constraint — luxury upgrades and step-ups.

Grand Seiko
SBGM221
39.5mm · Automatic$5,400
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Grand Seiko
SBGW258
38mm · Manual$26,000
Looks nearly identical · Similar size
Grand Seiko
SBGR261
39.5mm · Automatic$4,900
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Citizen
The Citizen Caliber 0200
40mm · Automatic$6,995
Common cross-shop · Visually similar
Oris
ProPilot X Calibre 400 Laser
39mm · Automatic$5,750
Automatic · Same size
Oris
Divers Sixty‑Five Chronograph
40mm · Automatic$4,700
Automatic · Same size
Vacheron Constantin
Patrimony Manual Winding 39mm White Gold Watch
39mm · Manual$27,800
Visually similar · Same size
NOMOS Glashütte
Tangente gold neomatik 38 Update
38.5mm · Automatic$16,100
Automatic · Same size
Bremont
Fury
40mm · Automatic$7,250
Automatic · Same size
Tudor
Monarch
39mm · Automatic$5,875
Automatic · Same size
Bremont
Audley
40mm · Automatic$7,250
Visually similar · Automatic
Vacheron Constantin
Patrimony Self Winding 40mm Pink Gold Watch
40mm · Automatic$38,200
Visually similar · Automatic
Looks like this· 5

Visually-adjacent picks pulled by the image-similarity engine. Quality varies — sometimes a true twin, sometimes just a rhyme.

Pagani Design
PD-1723
36.2mm · Automatic$171
Looks nearly identical · Automatic
Seestern
S424 Full Lume Pilot
38mm · Automatic$299
Automatic · Similar size
Seestern
S446 GMT
39.5mm · Automatic GMT$299
Visually similar · Same size
Sugess
MoonPhase Master S395
40mm · Automatic Moon Phase Enamel$599
Same size · 74% less
Sugess
Tourbillon Master SU8230
41mm · Automatic Tourbillon$1,399
Similar size · 39% less