Melbourne Watch Company Carlton
Finding alternatives to

Melbourne Watch Company Carlton

40 watches that match on case size, movement family, and price band. Sorted by how close the match is.

Case
42mm
Movement
Quartz
MSRP
$294
The short answer

The closest alternative to the Melbourne Watch Company Carlton is the Aigi Watches CHRONO BEERENBERG SC ($251) — looks nearly identical and Quartz. If price is the constraint, the Alexander James Watches Moon 38 at $100 (vs $294 for the Carlton) covers most of the same brief. From the independents, the Omologato Panamericana Chrono is the standout microbrand take — cushion case and Visually similar. Stepping up, the Hamilton Jazzmaster Chrono Quartz ($1,075) is where the same idea goes with a bigger budget.

40 matches
Microbrand picks· 12

Independent makers covering the same brief — usually with something the mainstream brands don't.

Omologato
Panamericana Chrono
41mm · Mecaquartz$604
Cushion case · Visually similar
Spinnaker
Hull Chronograph
42mm · Quartz$149
Cushion case · Quartz
Caught Watches
Aeris
40mm · Mecaquartz$261
Cushion case · Visually similar
Sunrex
Anemone City
40mm · Solar$530
Cushion case · Similar size
Farer
CUSHION CASE
38.5mm · $1,045
Cushion case · Looks nearly identical
Brew
Retrograph
38mm · Meca-Quartz$375
Racing chrono · Square case
Brew
8-Bit V2
38mm · Meca-Quartz$395
Cushion case · Sapphire
Farer
Lethbridge Gold
38.5mm · $1,085
Cushion case · Visually similar
Straton
Straton Curve Chrono MKII
42mm · Meca-Quartz$1,099
Racing chrono · Tonneau / barrel case
Straton
Straton Sportiva and Volante
38mm · Meca-Quartz$599
Racing chrono · Square case
Helgray
Superfast Automatic - Silver Panda
0mm · $799
Cushion case
Omologato
Reims
42mm · Quartz$530
Racing chrono · Visually similar
Mainstream picks· 12

Established brands covering the same brief at a comparable price — same case size, similar movement family. Often the deciding click for a new buyer.

Aigi Watches
CHRONO BEERENBERG SC
43mm · Quartz$251
Looks nearly identical · Quartz
Aigi Watches
CHRONO BEERENBERG BC
43mm · Quartz$251
Looks nearly identical · Quartz
Aigi Watches
CHRONO BEERENBERG BP
43mm · Quartz$251
Looks nearly identical · Quartz
Tissot
PRX
40mm · Quartz$450
Tonneau / barrel case · Visually similar
Tissot
PR516
40mm · Quartz$575
Racing chrono · Visually similar
Tissot
Chrono XL Vintage
45mm · Quartz$450
Racing chrono · Visually similar
Seiko
Coutura
42mm · Quartz$550
Racing chrono · Quartz
Seiko
Essentials Chronograph
41.5mm · Quartz$265
Racing chrono · Visually similar
Citizen
Promaster Land U822
43.9mm · Quartz$521
Racing chrono · Quartz
Marathon
CeraShell Pilot's Navigator
41mm · Quartz$550
Visually similar · Quartz
Seiko
Essentials Chronograph
40mm · Quartz$415
Racing chrono · Quartz
Citizen
Atomic Perpetual A-T
41mm · Solar
Racing chrono · Same size
Cheaper alternatives· 1

If the price is the only thing keeping you off this watch, these get you most of the way there for less.

Alexander James Watches
Moon 38
38mm · Quartz$100
Visually similar · Quartz
Pricier alternatives· 12

Where the same idea goes when budget isn't the constraint — luxury upgrades and step-ups.

Hamilton
Jazzmaster Chrono Quartz
42mm · Quartz$1,075
Racing chrono · Visually similar
Glycine
Airpilot Chrono
44mm · Quartz$1,895
Racing chrono · Visually similar
Seiko
Prospex SPEEDTIMER Seiko Brand 100th Anniversary SPEEDTIMER Limited Edition
42mm · Quartz$2,400
Racing chrono · Visually similar
Hamilton
Ventura Chrono Quartz
32mm · Quartz$1,245
Racing chrono · Quartz
Seiko
Astron
42mm · Quartz$2,500
Racing chrono · Visually similar
Bell & Ross
BR-S black matte
39mm · Quartz$2,916
Square case · Quartz
Citizen
Promaster Skyhawk U830
43mm · Quartz$596
Racing chrono · Quartz
Seiko
Astron GPS Solar 2025 Limited Edition
43.4mm · Quartz$2,900
Racing chrono · Visually similar
Citizen
Promaster Skyhawk A-T
42mm · Solar$1,500
Racing chrono · Visually similar
Citizen
Promaster Skyhawk A-T
45.7mm · Quartz$1,025
Racing chrono · Visually similar
Marathon
Steel Navigator SSNAV-D Quartz
41mm · Quartz$1,300
Visually similar · Quartz
Bell & Ross
BRS BLACK DIAMOND EAGLE DIAMONDS
39mm · Quartz$7,128
Square case · Quartz
Looks like this· 3

Visually-adjacent picks pulled by the image-similarity engine. Quality varies — sometimes a true twin, sometimes just a rhyme.

Pagani Design
PD-1725
42mm · Quartz$141
Racing chrono · Visually similar
Pagani Design
PD-YS012
41mm · Quartz$125
Racing chrono · Tonneau / barrel case
Pagani Design
PD-YS011
39.5mm · Quartz$142
Racing chrono · Tonneau / barrel case